Iran's Export Competitiveness in the Supply Chain of Tomato Paste in the Target Markets

Document Type : Research Article-en

Authors

• Gh. Ghasemi
• H. Rafiee
• E. Mehrparvar Hosseini

Department of Agricultural Economics, Faculty of Agriculture, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran

https://doi.org/10.22067/jead.2021.71505.1065

Abstract

Agricultural and food industry exports are one of the strategies for export development and sustainable economic growth in developing countries. Since Iran has been among the top ten countries in the export of tomatoes and tomato paste in recent years, the purpose of this article was to compare the global market structure of these two products as two links in the tomato supply chain and calculate the revealed comparative advantage of their exports in the world and the target countries. According to the results, the global market structure of both products in the period 2010-2018, despite the high share of the top four market powers, has been an open oligopoly for most of the years, which indicates a small share of the most competitors and high competition between them. However, due to the large share and stability of market leadership, it is unlikely that small countries will be able to capture the share of large countries. Therefore, it is suggested that Iran, with an average share of 1.61 percent in the tomato market and 5.30 percent in the paste market, prioritize a number of markets in which it has more competitiveness for market penetration, market development, and branding. On average, exports of tomatoes and tomato paste to Turkmenistan, Iraq, and Afghanistan have had the greatest comparative advantage for Iran. It is proposed to prioritize competition, market development, and branding in a number of markets in which it has competitiveness and stability based on the revealed comparative advantage index, including Turkmenistan and Afghanistan. It is worth mentioning that due to the higher comparative advantage of tomato paste compared to tomato, its higher added value, more branding, and storage and transportation capabilities, it is recommended, with the development of investment in food processing industries and the completion of supply chain and marketing. Development of the export market of tomato paste should be a priority of the country.

Keywords

• Export Target Market
• Revealed Symmetric Comparative Advantage
• Tomato paste
• World Market Structure

20.1001.1.20084722.1400.35.4.7.3

Main Subjects

• Marketing and Trade of Agriculture Production

References

1- Ahmadi, A., A. Kiani Rad. 2016. Assesment of Competitive Power of Iran in Global Market of Tomato Paste, The first national conference on new approaches in accounting and management, Mianeh, Iran. (In Persian).

2- Aminizadeh, M., H. Rafiee, A. Riahi, E. Mehrparvar Hosseini. 2014. Pattern of Competitiveness of Pistachios World Premier Exporters in Iran's Importers Market. Agricultural Economics 8(2): 41-68. (In Persian).

3- Amirnejad, H., S. Shahabi, H. Navidi. 2015. The Investigation of Trade Dimensions of Iran’s Raisins. Agricultral Economics and Development (23): 217-245.  (In Persian).

4- Behzadnia, P., N. Senobar, S. Hosseini. 2019. The Impact of Export Incentive Programs on Export Performance: The Role of the Attractiveness of Foreign Markets and Export Capabilities. Journal of International Business Administration 2(3): 63-85. (In Persian).

5- Farajzadeh, Z., M. Bakhshoodeh. 2011. Studying Pistachio World Market Structure with Emphasis on Iranian Market Power. Agricultral Economics and Development (73): 125-145 (In Persian).

6- Ferto, I., L. Hubbard. 2003. Revealed Comparative Advantage and Competitiveness in Hungarian. The World Economy, 26: 247-259.

7- Gajurel, D.P., R.S. Pradhan. 2012. Concentration and Competition in Nepalese Banking, Journal of Business, Economics & Finance, 1: 5-16.

8- International Trade Center. 2020. https://www.trademap.org/Index.aspx

9- Ishchukova, N., L. Smutka. 2013. Revealed comparative advantage of Russian agricultural exports. Acta Universitatis Agriculturae et Silviculturae Mendelianae Brunensis, 4.

10- Khodaverdizadeh, M., S. Mohammadi. 2017. Comparative Advantages and Analysis of International Market Structure of Medicinal Plants: Case Study of Anise, Badin, Fennel and Coriander (In Persian).

11- Maddala, G.C., S. Dobson, E. Millen. 1995. Microeconomics, The Regulation of Monopoly, Mc Grawhill Book Company Press.

12- Mahmoudi, A., H. Vali Beigi. 2004. Analysis of comparative advantages and prioritization of target markets for the export of Iranian dairy products, Ninth Conference on the Development of Non-Oil Exports, Tabriz Chamber of Commerce, Industries and Mines, Iran: 159-194 (In Persian).

13- Mehrparvar Hosseini, E. 2013. Factors Affecting Iran's Agricultural Trade Balance Behavior, M.Sc. Thesis, University of Tehran, Tehran. (In Persian).

14- Mehrparvar Hosseini, E., M. Aminizadeh, H. Rafiee, A. Riahi, M. Bastani. 2013. Designing of Iranian Dates Trade Model; Application of Trade Advantages and Theory of Market Structure. Agricultural Economics 7(2): 19-46. (In Persian).

15- Modarresi, M., S. Afrasiabi, H. Bagheri Garbollagh, and F. Khani. 2020. Prioritizing Export Target Markets of Tomato Iran Using Numerical Taxonomy Analysis (In Persian).

16- Microsoft Excel. 2019. Microsoft, LA, USA

17- Mirbagheri, S.SH., H. Rafiee, and H. Akbarpour. 2019. Market structure analysis and export pattern of Iranian saffron. Iranian Journal of Medicinal and Aromatic Plants 35(5): 802-818. (In Persian).

18- Palouj, M. 2018. Pathology of the Agro-industrial Exploitation System and Its Development Strategies. Iranian Agricultral Extension and Education Journal 14(2): 201-217 (In Persian).

19- Rafiee, H., S. Mirbagheri, H. Akbarpour, E. Jalili. 2018. Investigating the structure and compilation of the selection model for Iranian export markets. Business strategies Shahed University 25(12):66-76. (In Persian).

20- Salami, H., and E. Pishbahar. 2001. Changes in the Comparative Advantage Pattern of Agricultural Products in Iran: An Applied Analysis Using Expressed Comparative Advantage Indicators, Agricultural economics and development, 9 (34): 67-99. (In Persian).

21- Turkamani, J., and A. Zoghipour. 2008. Factors affecting the export supply of Iranian food industry products. Agricultural Economics, 2 (1), 23-33. (In Persian).